Cardboard Headliner

Trying to figure out what to do with my headliner, the rest of the interior is going to be black. My two thoughts are:
1. Paint it black
2. get some thin black vinyl from a fabric store and try to glue it to the headliner.

I had one painted black before and it looked okay, but I think the vinyl might look really good and hide the little bit of damage that is on it.

So was wondering if anyone has tried to put vinyl on one?

Or your thoughts on doing it.