Need to title a title-less car with no history- HELP!

Just apply for a lost title in Indiana, not hard to do, provided you have the owner who it was last registered too, assuming it is your dad, you should be fine. You'll need a police inspection in Indiana. You could also go the bill of sale route. Have your dad fill out the affidavit from the BMV stating he sold you the car for 1.00....problem solved, you get a new title.