monty hall passing away

adriver said
It's the Big Door he is looking behind now.
I wonder.....

Yea.
Exactly.
Keep it simple.
I took a moment and modified the graphics.
It becomes 50/50

Seems like some more confusion from the Mensa brain.
I would NOT want to tell this person they are wrong about something.

From wiki.
Vos Savant commented that, though some confusion was caused by some readers not realizing that they were supposed to assume that the host must always reveal a goat, almost all of her numerous correspondents had correctly understood the problem assumptions, and were still initially convinced that vos Savant's answer ("switch") was wrong.

View attachment 1715096464 View attachment 1715096466 View attachment 1715096467

Or put correctly another way.

View attachment 1715096468

I know some Mensa members, one passed away several years back in His 70's, another is ~20yrs. My junior, I refuse to take the test.......it simply doesn't interest Me.
Although I love solving problems/puzzles & logic teasers........
The initial fallacy above of assigning the tossed out 1/3 to the 2nd door is ridiculous, esp. when that 1/3 demonstrably a loser.
The Host is simply removing a known loser choice increasing Your odds(to 50/50) and giving You a "chance" to change Your mind.
It is true the odds for door #2 go up, but from 33.333333333% to 50%,..........not 66.6666666666%