I basically agree. Even around 1.5" I'd say its a crapshoot whether there's much to be gained. Depends a bit on the quality of the fuel distribution. Up around 2" Hg at the end, I totally agree. Just make sure your throttles are fully open with the pedal at the bottom when you do the test. (forgive me if that sounds basic, but its often overlooked)
Which ever one your most comfortable tuning. Honestly, I'd look for an old school Carter or Holley (pre 1990s) like a 4779 with a low - revision number. Less likely to have problems (and new carbs aren't cheap). Since you're running a Holley style now, there's the slight advantage of keeping the same fuel lines.