What Air Compressor Do You Have?

I don't. My electric company does. The difference is a big one.

If the 240v motor is comparable in hp rating to the 120v motor, they will use about the same amount of electricity.

I've always been told that it's better to go with a 240v unit since it draws half the amps per conductor (compared to an equally rated 120 unit), so there is less voltage drop.