Advice needed. A journal cap came off!

Well.....here's my point. No tellin what happened to that cap. No tellin how it was slapped around when it fell off. What it was beat against and how it was hit. If the crank throw hit it just right, it might not be round anymore. Too many mights and maybes for me. I mean Justin, we just don't KNOW what happened there. Can he file it down and make it work? Maybe. Will it lock up and break the crank? Maybe. Will it spin a main bearing. Maybe. Will it run for another 100K. Maybe. Till you pull it, tear it down and measure it, the maybes remain. Just too many maybes for me to armchair some advice and then feel responsible when his crank breaks slam in two on my recommendation. I don't seperate "mine" from "somebody else's" because I do everybody's like it was mine. Somebody doesn't wanna fix it the way I recommend and they wanna cut corners, there's somebody else down the road that can do it. You can ask anybody that's been around middle Georgia a while in the business about me and they might say something like "asshole", "sumbitch" and "prick", but they will also come right back and tell you I KNOW how to build an engine. I have a good reputation around here and I've kept it by not doin stupid **** (just my opinion, nothin personal) like reusin that main cap. LOL Just sayin.



My advice comes from what I would do, no difference just cause it's somebody else's sht.

Like I said.....if it's an old last leg'd motor and and the cap measures good, and the journal plasti gauged good all the way across 'wether mine or his'....I would give it a shot.

If it was a newly rebuilt motor I would yank it and tear it down, as in that case I would not want to chance wasting all the parts/money I just put into it.

My reputation is what ever the hell it is, some may think I'm a dk or that my sht ain't pretty and and expensive enough to impress them, the same people who don't listen to me.... so I fk them off and never help them again.
So many people out there want help and then disappear afterwards till the next time they need something again...

I'd rather hang by myself.