Sharktooth Headlight Bezel color question

Ok, heres the deal. Awhile ago I bought NOS left and right headlight bezels for my sharktooth grille from 2 different people at 2 different times. I never had them next to each other untill now.

The question is, they seem to be 2 different colors. The passenger side looks to be more white and the driver side looks to be more grey.

Which one is correct?