roof rail weatherstrip isnt fitting well

I remember the guy in the shop working on the car saying the old gaskets look good I'd leave them. I didn't see the roof rail new verses old at the time since I was shipping directly to the shop. Should have left the old ones on. I was thinking 40+ years old better with new ones. I was assuming the new ones were just like the existing ones. Boy was I wrong. I still have the old roof rail gaskets. I may have to see if they can go back on.

The original roof rails on the 67 GTS had two profiles in the one gasket. It change profile at the rear window. Someone here said they got one from Steel Rubber and it fit good. I call steel Rubber and asked them about their gasket. They said it had two proflies so I ordered them. Hope I don't have to send them back. Getting tired of send back stuff that doesn't fit. Going thru that with the plug wires too.