Best Western I've ever seen

I dunno: Maybe I'm not old enough, but *some* of the new stuff is pretty tough to beat. You guys need to get out more:

The remake of True Grit is incredible.

Have you seen Appaloosa? Ed Harris and Viggo Mortensen. Pretty damn good.

Older recent stuff:
Unforgiven is right up there also. I don't know about the whole movie but Val Kilmer rocked in Tombstone. If its gotta be an older movie, my money is still on Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid.

No I take it all back: No Country for Old Men is the top, but its not set in the 1880s so it might not count for some folks. If you take the more modern setting out of it though, its 100% Western and Western themes.