Who is BS'ing who?

I agree with you. I wouldnt doubt your bike got better mpg at 75 in 6th as apposed to 6th at 55 because as you said it was working at optimal rpm of the engine to make power. It probably uses a tiny bit more gas, but you are also covering more ground faster, Giving you better mpg so the little extra gas you use doesnt out weigh the ground you covered. Of course it probably would have even gotten better mpg working in the same rpm range say in 5th going 45, but this isnt the case because that is too slow for the highway. He and I did not claim faster in general = better mpg. Just at certain speeds at a certain rpm. I am no expert, but this is just my thinking on it.

yea it sounds like it should work like that, except it always takes more power to go faster and more power requires more fuel, the increase in speed can never overcome the increase in fuel consumption,
they are called the "laws of thermodynamics" and they are the most basic fundamental principals upon which all mechanical things operate,