That's why I didn't try fitting it in there yet - I thought perhaps squeezing it in there with the two different ridge patterns might do just that! Figured it was better to ask the question first :D
Edit: looked at the supposed NAPA part (Balkamp) for the application and it sure looks similar to the Dorman version.
I just replaced mine and that is what the replacement look like. You won't find studs that look like the old ones anywhere. I used a press and they went in nice and tight and they work fine.