There is a thread on here from a member that went through the same thing as you are and he won in the end.
Someone help me out here. The car above was like a 73 to 75 Cream/Tan 4 door Valiant or Dart that is owned by a member on the upper west coast. He has a picture of that car and a 1940s model 2 door car in his avatar. His advise might help the op in dealing with the insurance companies.