727 doesn't shift into second gear like it should

If I dropped the pan could I just push on the servo to see if it feels springy or solid. Or would the spring be too stiff to push in?

It's too stiff to tell.

Best I remember there is no spring in the front servo. It will slide up and down in the hole. But it was ran like this before the rebuild. I have a couple spare 727's so parts are no problem. Just have to make sure what will and won't interchange because the other 2 are later models.

No spring at all? Just slides up and down in the hole? That's a major problem. It needs something in there if for no other reason to make it release all the way so the front band doesn't drag. I use 2 springs to make sure it doesn't apply too fast and releases quicker.