Package tray resto

Vinyl die would be my first choice for painting it. I got my new one from Dante's Parts. His shipping is much less then Year Ones. However my new one doesnt fit all that great. Its about 1" short.
Hi, I was just thinking of getting a new package tray for my 1970 Dart from Dante's. My old one does not have speaker cut outs and it is ripped in half. Does yours look OK? Do you regret getting it? Thanks.
Gary