Ever look at old pics of your car?

Now see there, I'm just the opposite of rob_robinson87, pacuda59, and BigBlockMopar. My feeling is that aftermarket wheels also imply you've made other changes as well like under the hood.
To me, stock-appearing wheels say nothing's changed from the day it rolled out of the dealership.
Some like the stock look, I like the "I've worked on it and it's something special" look.
But in the end, it's your car and it only has to make you happy.