what kind of rims should i buy.....?

For the B5 blue in the photo, I'd prefer a set of rallye wheels with T/As, letters out. Use the 70 (bright) wheel center.

The Cragars look good, but they seem pretty common as aftermarket wheels go. For something different, check out Ansen Sprint wheels. They were made in a Mopar SBP. They turn up on eBay or CL from time to time. American Racing still makes the center caps and lugs, but no longer makes a SBP wheel according to their website.