2357 tail lite bulbs or 1157?

You don't HAVE to get them from Honda.
Look for the nickle base and a good brand.

Yeah, you do have to get them from Honda if you want the money to be worth spending. The Honda parts pipeline is the only way to get real ones made by Stanley. All the rest -- with or without nickelplate base -- are Chinese junk that doesn't meet the output specs and doesn't last (though I notice that doesn't stop GE, Wagner, Sylvania, etc. from charging top dollar).