71 Demon 318 Auto or 72 Demon 340 4 speed

Before you think I have a screw loose, hear me out. The 71 needs nothing but to be driven (nothing special, it is a yellow 318, auto car and the 318 was rebuilt a bit ago but is reliable), and the hemi orange 72 is missing a windshield, has not moved or even been started in 20 years, and the owner claims it is a barn find.

The 71 is down the street and the 72 is quite a drive (and the guy selling is real bad with computers so pictures are pretty much awful). I know the difference in cosmetics and the difference in fun factor of the 4 speed over the auto, I just wanted to conduct an informal poll to see what other members here thought. Both are within a few bucks between each other (think mid 5k range)...or are both sellers crazy? I am much better with Barracuda prices than I am with Dodge Demon prices...