Tool list 2GO

If you carry a spare you don't need the fix-a-flat. I'm probably gonna take a lot of heat for saying this from the believers in it, but it's true! I would warn against using it at all unless it's the absolute last resort. Once you use fix-a-flat in a tire it can no longer be properly reapired. The tire patches won't properly vulcanize to the tire because of the f-a-f. I've seen many tire plugs not hold because of it too. It's intended for an emergency situation & as a last resort. Since many of us use good tires on our beloved classics, it would be a shame to have to replace an otherwise good repairable tire because of it.
As for the rest of the tool box, I think a basic set of screwdrivers, basic 3/8" socket set w/ extensions, combination wrenches, a test light, a flashlight & a hammer is probably all you would need. And yes plenty of tape!
I like the idea of a restored car & a restored nostagic tool box to go with it. Something period correct of course!