Need weatherstrip help

Interesting. I'm not seeing a match for your old weatherstrip in either the Restoration Specialties or the Gary Goers catalog (see here) but I was never much good at those "Which of these five patterns is the same as the sample pattern, only rotated?" types of puzzles. That said, I do not agree that the new weatherstrip is a match for the old by rotating it 180°. Is it possible the old weatherstrip you're replacing is not the original, but an earlier replacement of the incorrect type?