650 proform carb leak down troubles

No i didn't try the power valve that was next.
I really wanted an electric choke on it anyway.
I'm happy with my descision. starts fine now.
It ran too rich with that carb anyway.

Did you ever check the power valve? I just had the exact same problem with a new Holley 750HP I installed and when I took it apart to check it out I found the power valve gasket wasn't sealing. Installed a new gasket and it starts fine every time now. IMO you took a step back going to an Edelbrock