5.2 vs 5.9 ram pros and cons ??

That's a toughy between the first 2 candidates! I personally like the 5 speed and the truck its in because its cleaner! For the amount of towing vs. straight driving you'll do, I think it would better serve your purpose!
I just don't like the rot on that red one!! Geof

Agreed. You're in Kentucky, you shouldn't have to own a rusty truck. Us Northern guys are another story. Go for the stick truck!