$9650? For this?

I appreciate what you're doing and have no problem with your brother selling the car. My problem lies with the guy who bought it and is now trying unsuccessfully to flip it. If you list your car on eBay, take good pictures and write a decent description, the last bid is EXACTLY what your car is worth at that time and in that place. If someone thought it was worth more, they would have bid $3501, but no one did. He can list it for $10k on Craigslist for the rest of his life for all I care, but he's probably going to own it that long.