new starting issue, help before I have to call dr hook

how are you checking your battery, a volt meter will only give you a reading of a surface charge, you also need to to a specific gravity test with a hydrometer ( should be 12.75 ) in each and use a proper carbon pile battery load tester, not a wafer tester, you probably wont have one but most parts stores do and usually will test it for free, also a bad starter, (as well as many other things ) will also cause the solenoid to click you could try jumping it direct start with the battery