Tell me what you think of this deal...

The seller oversold the item. That is a fact. How to prove that? Unless it was a NOS fender pulled off a dealership shelf after sitting for 40 plus years, it would be possible for anyone to find a nicer fender (ie: a NOS one) then the one he was selling. And the patch section for the marker light? If he has sold other parts (which another post in this thread indicates), then he would know the fix that was done to the fender.

Not cool.