Tell me what you think of this deal...

Welcome the the mopar world. Expect to pay twice as much for parts compared to brand X. That quarter actually looked better than the front fenders on my dart before my rebuild. This is 45 year old sheet metal and there are no perfect original sheet metal out there at that price anyway. In my opinion you got a fair deal from a great member. I have bought and sold hundreds of used mopar parts. Got burned a little on some and others I came out golden. To me it's not worth the wasted energy and stress of starting and maintaining a thread like this. Move on.