Miles per gallon?

I personally get 17 mixed MPG with a two barrel carb and 3.23 gears on my slant. With a one barrel carb and I assume stock gears you ought to be getting a lot higher than 10-11. Have you done a tune up recently? Valve lash set? Is the carburetor mixture set properly? Maybe timing is off? Lotsa little things can help or hurt.

Well, we thought that it was being caused by a bad thermostat. The car was never getting any warmer than slightly above the "C." After replacing the thermostat, the car gets much warmer and operates at a reasonable temperature (as a bonus, I am not freezing as I drive.). Here is the breakdown in case my calculations are off: 23217 at top off #1, drive for a few days and re-fill at 23343. 23353-23217=136. I put in 10.5 gallons, 136/10.5=12.95. (I did just notice I was a few miles off in my calculations earlier, but 12.95 still seems low.) I took a picture of the odometer at each fill so I know that to be accurate.

My father is a mechanic by trade and says the carb appears to be in tune, not to mention the fact the car flawlessly. It has pretty old tires on it, but I can't think of what else could be causing such poor fuel economy.

Also, that is the third top-off/calculation I have done. The other two came out at 10.5 and 11.2 mpg.

Aside from a carb-tuning and valve lashing (which I am not all that familiar with, but I do know the cars run poorly when they need it.)

What else could be causing this?