Horrible MPG/Fuel odor troubleshoot

I don't know who "they" are, but IMO, they are wrong. I've read all about that too and known people who've done it. It just never works as well as tuning with a power valve correctly.

Also, what I was getting at is, if it has a power valve and it is ruptured, that could be the whole problem.

Agreed on the power valve statement. Before we knew about the check valve trick or Holley doing it themselves it could get expensive going through power valves if you had a backfire. The plugging of the power valve was mainly recommended for applications where idle vacuum was so low because of a radical cam that the vacuum at WOT was enough to close the weak valve and cause a lean out. Not a good thing. Intermediate fuel mixture was always over rich but for "on-off" drag applications it was functional. It also became a crutch for lazy tuners or handy for out board carbs on mechanical six pack setups.