Latest opinions on socket clip/ bars?

I have had the HF ones for years. The price is right and I liked them better than the Craftsman ones when I bought them. The Craftsman ones held the sockets too tight and were hard to get off when your hands are greasy.

But do they stay on when you want them? The ones I looked at did not look very impressive. On the other hand, "they are cheap." It would not cost very much to try them

What I want is something "hardy" that can live in the tool box. We are not talking about "bench" work. We are talking about being bounced around in the pickup and so on.