I'm running the 6270. Mine does not put out too much pressure and I do not have a return line. I see 7psi cold and 5- 6 or so when hot. Heard about some of them putting out too much and was prepared for it but mine is just fine.
FWIW the Edelbrock and Holley High volume pumps BOTH showed numbers just like yours on the dyno, and even lower. The Carter was my last shot at a mechanical. So far, so good.