Stalls in Gear, Automatic- Restarts Good- Can Slam it into Gear! EEEK

It could, it might not. One tooth is ~9 degrees. It would be obvious when driving it, but may not present well at idle, especially with a stock cam. Heck, it should still idle in gear even if it skipped a tooth.

hmmm, well for how its running im surprised it doesn't stay running too