Bought a MSD 8534 off a member here ( see Photo of what I got)

I agree with^^, That was my thought that the seller had not had the cap off in a while and especially before he sent it to me. That is why I asked him in my first contact after receiving it "I got home today. The packaging was great , the outside looked great. Have you looked inside of it lately?" It was his attack on me that caught me off guard.
Like I said I was shocked when I pulled the cap off of mine, I'm not really sure what an acceptable resolution will be between you and the seller but I know and as others have stated, for whatever reason, those MSD distributors seem to naturally get that way with the moisture in the air I guess.