Main bearing cap broken how to repair

This is the part that I am not wholly convinced is true, over the long term with heat cycles and vibration, pump torque, and a paper gasket between. It only has to creep a few thousandths to start sideloading the pump shaft, etc. Buuuuut, I can't prove it; perhaps too much imagination.

The problem with that theory is that there is no provision either in the pump input drive or the inside of the locating hole it the cap for surface to surface contact.
Surfaces don't match or anything, and if it was made to contact there it wouldn't be a cast surface but a bushing in the hole.
Also I have never seen contact marks of any kind inside there on any pump ever.