Temp Too Low???

If you installed a sensor into the WP, you must have drilled and tapped a hole for it, as the stock WPs have no such port.
Sorry, should've mentioned its a replacement water pump, I figured it didn't matter because its just a generic NAPA part, factory replacement. I'm running an equus gauge, since the only factory gauges that have ever worked on this car are the speedo and the volt meter. The main reason I havent used the factory gauges is convenience, I got a temp, fuel and oil temp gauge in a box when I bought the car, so I've just been slowly installing them on the car as I've needed, because hey, I'm not paying any extra.
So frustrating trying to diagnose things over the Internet without pictures.
Hope this helps, sorry, I don't have access to the car at the moment, just trying to get some research done while she's out of my hands. I dont have any pictures of the engine with the sensor attached, but I have it routed through that blocked off point on the pump. Circled in red there

2017-02-11-20-20-19.png