Craigslist 4 Speed - Something doesn't jive?

I didn't count the splines yet, but it looks like 23. I ran the numbers stamped on it and comes back to 72 and based on the diagrams is an A body. Any way I can tell for sure? I am already nervous I may have been ripped off.

Show some pics of the input shaft and casting number of the tail housing.

It's an a-body trans. If that is what you were looking for you got it.

You can open it up and count the markings on the gears to verify the ratios being wide (2.66 1st) or close (2.44 1st).

ID Guide is on the Brewer trans website.

Issue would be from the inside gears Being rusty or engaging teeth being toasted (worn/chipped flat). Did you open it up and inspect?

Did the seller say the insides looked good?