67 Dart 273 timing issue

duster360 said
Put a screwdriver in that gear, turn it to pop it up and rotate it 1 tooth and drop it back in. It will probably be exactly where you want it.

That is what I thought, but it is not a gear. It is a five sided stud that drops into the oil pump. It can either go into either the four or seven o'clock positions. Or other positions that are way off.