Speedometer off

So when I get the old one out if it is in fact a 33, then I’ll look for a 37, that would put me closest to 60 by your calculations
I chose 33 based on this chart. (I guessed you had 26" tires and a 3.21 rear ratio) but yes based on the math if you have 33 teeth now you would need 37 to get the closest.
upload_2018-3-16_23-27-25.png