Convertible Top company

Did you try SMS Auto fabrics out of Oregon? If anybody has the correct material, it would be them!

Also, for your reference, the only 1967 Barracuda Formula S 383 automatic convertible made was blue on blue, with a blue convertible top! A member here had owned it and offered it to me, but it was a big project that I couldn't take on! It also had blue headrests on the bucket seats, an almost impossible to find color option. She sold it not long ago, I hope it found a good home and is being redone!
Yep that's mine, blue on blue with a soon to be blue convertible top. The company looked through their records and called Haartz, a big convertible/vinyl company in Maryland, and neither had ever made a blue top for a 67 Barracuda. Like you, my Barracuda buddy said he'd never seen a blue top on a car and had only heard of one. Might of been your friends car.