Help, 4 speed console via automatic console

The two are quite different, The 4 speed as you can see has a screw and a clip on the drivers side cut out. In this area is a paper/ wax (Not sure what its made of) cover. This creates a "Hump" under which is the shifter mechanism. Making an Auto into a 4 speed could be done, would it look right.....Not sure? Would it function right...maybe , Yes