I did, but not advised. Yes, the aluminum pump is ~1" thicker. I had to get creative with pulleys and belts, and no way to fit a clutch-fan. I went that way because a neophyte and bought the only radiator they listed at Autozone (for ~1972) and picked the aluminum pump to match the radiator, plus it was half the cost and I thought less corrosion since bolting an iron pump to an aluminum timing cover to an iron block = "battery". Good that I removed the timing cover to change the camshaft since I found it was almost corroded thru (leaks coolant into crankcase).