Stop in for a cup of coffee

I've decided to go with the 255/60/15 tires. The 275/60/15's Im worried would rub the fenders in cornering and with full tread. I like the look of them, but just a bit to much and dont want the worries. Now what tire to go with, only 2 options..

Cooper Cobra Radial GT $106
BF Goodrich Radial T/A $173

Thoughts??