Fuel delivery problem; maybe?

I checked power at the starter and i have power there; so i'm guessing the starter gave up on me.

Could the starter have been my culprit the whole time?
No, if it was the starter, it would not start at all.

Where do you have power? At the large wire, or the small wire on he starter? The large wire should have battery voltage all the time. The small wire should have more then 10 volts, when the key is in the start position.