OE gas tank “spacer”? Yea...step on in!

I would not think you want anything compressible. Maybe some rectangular aluminum tubing, say, 1" X 3-4" wide or so, front to back, both sides right inline with the straps. In fact, "I guess" you might be able to cut them long, with a slot/ hole in the end to index the strap and keep them aligned before tightening. Us thin pad material above and below the tubing

I'm guessing that you're on to something here!