Stop in for a cup of coffee

Welcome to the coffee shop Heather!
I wanted a stock look, so used same tire all around. I went with what I found the largest that fit WELL on the front - 215 70 14. If the link works right this should show the comparison to what you are running now. Tire Size Comparison
As for the back, Ramie @straightlinespeed just did his, not sure what sizes. I know he did big back small front, but I believe was running 15's. There is also a wheels and tires thread that could be very helpful.
Keith
I had the back tire in that comparison. Your current front is actually shorter, but slightly wider than the 215 70 14, Tire Size Comparison
I have 5.5 wide wheels, if those are 7 inch wheels, that could also make them take a slightlywider profile. I'm assuming it is hitting the front lower corner of the opening...