Door Panel opinions needed

I used the vinyl paint from O’Reillys on a boat seat 25 years ago. It has been out in the weather & sun a lot. Looks about the same after all this time. Doesn’t scratch or flake at all. Mine was dark brown, so it covered really well. Cleaning is critical. Didn’t sand or rough it up at all.

I also tried the light brown on a convertible top. Didn’t work very well there. Soaked in and wouldn’t cover.