Finally the decision has been made.

Make the final valve spring decision first. If you end out with true dual springs, then you'll have no choice but to turn down the guide OD and use Viton seals.

FWIW, i've always thought the length of the umbrella is just to make sure they extend below the top of the guide when they ride up on the stems.
Btw do you know if the umbrella seals will work with the dampers or not?