Classic Industries Sharktooth Grill

I ordered a sharktooth grill for my 71 Scamp and it arrived today and it looks spectacular! Except apparently when assembled 2 of the screws and nuts from the parking lights weren't tightened, and came loose and they were rolling all over. The upper part of the front has some minor scratches. If I didn't pay what I did it wouldn't bother me so much. Debating whether I should call for a replacement, but will it be worse?

sharktooth.jpg