Any more now days I look at the most expansive and then the cheapest and try to find something in the middle of the road. I purchased Douglas tires and had Wally change and balance, a course I just took the rims in, without the center and beauty rim. I could not trust them to fully understand left and right lugs nuts... Douglas tires I am pretty sure Goodyear makes, but are under Wally's store brand, I choose the same tire size you mentioned.
