Crazy alignment problems

Wow this is a lot of information. Looks like I have way more to look into than I thought.
After reading all of this I’ll probably just tear the whole front end apart and start over. Because when I moved I had to just throw the car together good enough to get it on a trailer. Every post on this thread makes a lot of sense.
I’ll post better pictures before I start tearing everything down to try and answer some of your questions.
I’ve got to replace the throw out bearing in my daily before I dig into the Duster though.

Thanks again everyone. This is a huge help.