Auto Console Shifter: Five Positions?

Linkage not properly adjusted, play in entire system, wrong linkage pieces, wrong transmission lever. Or the button is not actually releasing. Can you tell that it is actually going into park?

One thing you could do is go underneath at each end of the travel......P and 1, and pull the link out and then see if the lever moves further.

Any chance the shaft is loose on the transmission lever, or worse, that the "rooster comb" in the transmission is loose on the shaft?